Friday, March 24, 2017

Feb. 17, 2017 Legislative Update

Rep. Anne Donahue
Legislative Update
February 17, 2017

Vermont is moving forward with efforts at health care reform at the same time as watching and waiting to see how Washington will address the future of the Affordable Care Act.
Those monitoring tasks are among the priorities that my Health Care Committee has identified for this session, along with review and input on the state’s budget and addressing the crisis-level pressures on our mental health system. They will dominate our committee work, although we are also taking up some specific bills.
***
Medicaid pilot
The payment reform plan known as the “all payer” model (it doesn’t actually include all payers, but it has the big three: Medicare, Medicaid and Vermont commercial) is in what is called “year zero.” That is the planning year; year one will be when it goes into effect next year.
The insurers will be paying a group of medical providers, called an accountable care organization (ACO), which will reimburse doctors for all care to patients who see a primary doctor who is a member of the ACO.
Vermont’s Medicaid program will be giving it a trial run this year with providers of patients in the northwest and northcentral parts of the state (including ours). Hospitals in those counties and the primary care doctors working for them will get money up front each month for meeting patient needs and helping them to avoid higher cost care.
During the pilot, Medicaid will be tracking all the actual services patients get, and what those services would have cost if they were being paid per-service. Quality measures will also be tracked.
Will it actually bring good results?
Here is what Vermont’s Medicaid administrators told us:
“Like any new program, we cannot guarantee that it will succeed.”
“Financial Projections: Numbers are being developed without experience. Not clear whether number will be too little or too much. Missing the mark may impact program performance and perceptions of the program.”
“Operations: Implementation challenges are likely to occur in the first months of any new program. Such challenges can affect public perception of the program, and may poison the well for other statewide readiness activities during Year 0 of the All Payer Model agreement.”
What incredibly refreshing honesty!
In fact, it is a more refined way of saying what I have said for a while about the All Payer Model. There are clear possibilities that it will not result in the hoped-for savings. But it is something that seems rational to try, and certainly better than doing nothing while the costs of healthcare skyrocket beyond reach.
The governor’s decision to do this test run first will allow us to back out if it does not demonstrate good outcomes.
Our committee will also be watching the implementation process closely.
***
Affordable Care Act
Major changes to – or total repeal of – “Obamacare” would have a profound impact on health care in Vermont. Our uninsured rate dropped from eight to four percent under expanded eligibility for Medicaid and with the premium assistance for Vermont Health Connect insurance plans.
If that rate moved back up, we would see the impact in areas such as “free care” provided by hospitals; it’s not actually free, as the cost is shifted to other payers, so it would show up in insurance rates.
Some key provisions that could come to an end would be the ban on annual and lifetime limits on essential health care and the ban on copays for preventive care. It could also bring an end to the annual maximum amount that someone has to pay in co-pays or deductibles. Those protections do not exist in Vermont law.
One well-known (and popular) part of the ACA is its ban on excluding coverage of pre-existing conditions. When you enroll in an insurance plan, it can’t tell you, “no coverage for your diabetes; you already have it.”
There is a rational reason for this traditional exclusion. Expecting coverage is sort of like saying you should be able to buy car insurance and have it pay for the fender you crumpled the week before.
If you could get health coverage for an expensive illness after you get the illness, why would anyone bother to buy insurance until they are already sick? And if the only people buying insurance are already sick, that insurance is going to be extremely expensive. It defeats the whole point of sharing risk by having a large group pay into a pool for those who end up needing it.
The Affordable Care Act addressed that problem through the (very unpopular) insurance mandate. If everyone is required to have insurance, there is no longer the problem of having people only get coverage after they are sick, so “pre-existing conditions” are no longer a problem to cover. So these two provisions really need to go hand-in-hand.
President Trump has already directed the IRS to stop enforcing the individual mandate. (It is enforced through the health insurance coverage form required with your tax return.) That places the ban on exclusion of pre-existing conditions in jeopardy.
That is one feature Vermont had in place, in part, before the ACA, so we could restore it. We required a new insurance plan to cover pre-existing conditions as long as a person had been maintaining insurance coverage at least up to six months prior.
That protected people who did have coverage, but needed to change plans, for example as a result of a job change.
What remains unclear for now is what other protections we could, as a state, preserve.

***
Budget Pressures
A major budget pressure this year is the crisis in our mental health system. Patients often wait for days – yes, multiple days – in emergency rooms because no hospital beds are available.
We held a joint hearing with the Senate Health and Welfare Committee last week to hear from front line workers about the severity of the problems, which includes the lack of capacity for geriatric psychiatry for elders, lack of adequate staffing, and lack of resources for mobile crisis services.
Some of the most compelling testimony came from staff at Central Vermont Medical Center and the Vermont Psychiatric Care Hospital.
Our committee will be making recommendations to the Appropriations Committee for the budget that is currently in development, as well as in further review later during the session.
***
Bills in Committee
We have identified five bill proposals that are priorities for testimony and consideration in our committee:
-          Copays for physical therapy. A proposal to limit insurance copays for physical therapy to the same as primary care. The theory is that encouraging the use of physical therapy may prevent higher-end health care costs, such as surgery.
-          Worker’s comp coverage for PTSD. If a person has a diagnosed condition of post traumatic stress disorder that resulted from an occupational hazard, why would it not be covered in the same way as other work related injuries or illnesses? A first responder coping with having intervened in a horrific tragedy comes to mind, and this is not currently covered.
-          A commission for in-depth post-incident reviews of mental health crisis responses that result in death or serious injury. This review of law enforcement and mental health crisis worker efforts would focus on the background and causes of such outcomes. We can learn a lot when, instead of pointing fingers, we look at what might be done differently in the future. We already heard testimony from law enforcement agencies and advocates very supportive of this bill.
-          Allowing consent by a minor for mental health counselling about sexual orientation issues. This waiver already exists for getting treatment for substance abuse or sexually transmitted diseases. If a teen would avoid getting help rather than allowing parents to know the situation, likely even the youngster’s parents would prefer that getting treatment came first.
-          Suicide data review. This bill would direct the Department of Mental Health to review suicide deaths in Vermont to look for causes, similarities, or trends -- something not currently done. Our rate of death by suicide is 30 percent higher than the national average. It is hard to address a problem without knowing, “Why?”
***
On the House Floor
Last week, the Judiciary Committee presented a bill on a new crime that bans “open and gross lewdness.” It is being created as a lesser offense than the current crime of “open and gross lewdness and lascivious behavior.”
Problem: we have no definition in current law for the existing, “lewd and lascivious” conduct, let alone segmenting out when it is merely lewd, but not lascivious. According to the legislator reporting on the bill, it is simply recognized based on social norms.
(Dare I say it comes under the standard, “I know it when I see it?”)
That hardly gives a fair warning about what conduct might get you arrested for a crime.
My questions brought a round of “no” votes, but the bill still passed.
Afterwards, new legislator and retired judge Ben Joseph, who sits adjacent to me, leaned across the aisle both literally and figuratively to tell me that he thought my points were exactly correct.
***
Thank you for the honor of representing you. Please contact me with your questions and your opinions. You can reach me by message at home at 485-6431, at the statehouse at 828-2228, or at this email at counterp@tds.net



Sunday, February 5, 2017

Feb 3, 2017 Legislative Update

Legislative Update
February 3, 2017
Rep. Anne Donahue

The first lengthy, contentious and partisan debates occurred in the House last week.
One was almost purely symbolic, on a proposal by Rep. Paul Poirier of Barre City that he said was intended as a way for him to be able to show his opposition to the governor’s school budget proposal.
The other was highly substantive, with the House voting to re-open a settled election after the person who lost made a complaint to the legislature.
***
School Budgets
The school vote came about when Rep. Poirier tried to amend a minor bill by adding a change in the date for voting on school budgets from March to May. That was a change proposed by Governor Phil Scott in his budget address as a part of an aggressive initiative to reshape our education funding process.
Poirier opposed his own amendment and urged others to defeat it.
Delaying local budget votes would have been the only way for the legislature to have a serious discussion on the various elements of the governor’s proposal this year.
The proposal included the unpopular idea of having zero increases in budgets, and the popular idea of shifting money into pre-school and college education. (It seems to be human nature to want to be getting something for nothing.)
The amendment was defeated, 87-47.
Given that it was essentially acknowledged to be a symbolic vote, I voted for it to express my disappointment that, yet again, we won’t take up any serious cost containment or funding reform this year.
***
Election Recount
Earlier in the week, we voted on a recommendation by the Government Operations Committee to have our own members conduct a second recount of the ballots in the Orange-1 district (Williamstown, Chelsea, Corinth, Orange, Vershire, Washington, and West Fairlee).
The House, under the state constitution, has the right to rule on the qualifications of its members, so the question was whether the winner of the election was qualified – in other words, whether he won the election fairly.
Rep. Patti Lewis gave a sterling “minority report” from the four Republicans on the committee.
It was pretty generally acknowledged that there was no evidence that there was any fraud or misconduct in the election. There had already been one recount, a judge had verified the outcome of the recount, and another judge has rejected a request for a second recount. So the losing candidate came to the legislature.
The only cloud over the election was the fact that the loser was complaining about it, but the majority party decided that the only way to lift that cloud – to ensure confidence in the system – was for the House to conduct a recount.
I argued that we needed to have some basic reason that called an outcome into question before holding a recount. Otherwise, any losing candidate could get a recount by the House, by virtue of creating such a “cloud” by simply calling out, “it wasn’t fair.”
That argument failed, and the final vote was 76-59 to authorize the recount. (A few brave Democrats, and most of the Independents, voted with the Republicans.)
If as a body we had been bending over backwards to protect the rights of a minority among our members, there might have been some honor in this vote. The election’s 7-vote winner, however, was a Republican, which made this effort by the majority party quite disturbing.
The one small victory in the course of the 5-hour debate was adoption of my amendment to require the Government Operations Committee to return to the House for approval of the policies and procedures they develop to conduct the recount.
Amazingly, the committee was asking for House authority for the recount without saying how it would be done, and refusing to even agree to follow the guidance of state law for recounts. As the committee’s chair told me under questioning on the floor, the constitution allows the House to handle a recount in any way it wants… so the committee was going to develop its own procedures.
Thanks to my amendment, those procedures will now require full House approval before the recount can occur.
The downside, since the committee had not developed them in advance, is that we’ll have to face another long debate when we review them. Agreeing to follow state law would have saved a lot of time. It would also have done a lot more to create confidence that there are no underhanded intentions.
***
Drug Pricing
In my Health Care Committee last week, we heard from the Attorney General’s office on the outcome of last year’s bill to force some transparency from pharmaceutical companies that jack prices way up on their drugs.
Our committee worked on a tri-partisan basis to develop a consensus bill to require explanation of major price increases. While many states have complained about the impact of these increases on state Medicaid budgets, we are the only state to take action.
We did it carefully to protect confidential “trade secrets” and one result was that, rather than suing us, the companies complied.
Unfortunately, by allowing the Attorney General to keep trade information confidential, the information that was released to us was pretty watered down into general information, instead of being drug-specific or company-specific. It didn’t provide any real insights into how they justify the pricing.
The companies have “pricing committees” that assess when to change a drug’s price. The factors they said they consider in deciding to increase a price included cost effectiveness (meaning the value to patients given the effectiveness of the drug compared to other drugs); the size of the patient population for the drug; investments made and the risks undertaken; creation and maintenance of manufacturing facilities; cost of ingredients; competition, including for drugs in the same class; return on investment; and the percentage of their sales in commercial, Medicare or other government channels.
What was fascinating to me was the result of the state’s work in identifying the ten drugs that we were asking for information on. The criteria – something I suggested just based on what sounded unreasonable as an increase on an existing drug – was to develop a list of existing drugs that had a price increase of 50 percent or more over the past five years or 15 percent or more over the past 12 months.
There were a stunning 8,221 drugs that fit the 50 percent increase category, and 3,975 that fit the 15 percent within one year category. No wonder the average cost per prescription for specialty drugs has tripled over the past seven years.
Pharmacies aren’t the ones seeing that increase. Even chain pharmacies are only making a net profit of about two percent, while the pharmaceutical firms are at 22 percent.
We are determined to try to reshape our new law this year so that we can squeeze more transparency out, while keeping within the required confidentiality laws.
***
Silliness
Silly bill of the month: A proposal to fine stores that prop open their outside doors if the heat or air conditioning is running. OK, I get it. Someone’s worried about energy efficiency. But it seems that stores would want to watch their own energy bills, and if the door is propped open, there might just be some other reason.
Do we really want to send energy police around to hunt down stores that have a wedge in the door?
This bill does offer a good opportunity to remind folks that hundreds of bills are introduced each year, some of them purely on the request of someone’s constituent. It doesn’t mean it will get even five minutes of a reviewing committee’s time.
When the news media highlights a newly introduced bill it can create an automatic misperception that it is under serious consideration. It might just be that it caught a reporter’s eye as unusual or silly… just as I am doing with this “door prop” bill.
***
Thank you for the honor of representing you. Please contact me with your questions and your opinions. You can reach me by message at home at 485-6431, at the statehouse at 828-2228, or at this email at counterp@tds.net


Sunday, January 22, 2017

January 20 2017 Legislative Update

It is hard to believe as I write this that we are already three weeks into the new legislative biennium. There is very little “action” to report.
The glorious thing about a citizen legislature is that we come from all walks of life, bringing diverse backgrounds to the job. The flip side, of course, is that we bring no expertise to most of the subjects that will come before us.
I have been re-appointed to the Health Care Committee, where six of the 11 members are new to the committee, and five are first-time legislators. There is a whole lot of information for them to absorb about the many components and issues that make up our health care system and that are in the jurisdiction of our committee.
Most of our time thus far has been spent on hearing overviews from the many players in that system. There has been little time spent on the House floor, since bills are not yet being voted out of any committees.
We are also just beginning to get to know one another. We will be spending a lot of time together these next four months. The bulk of the work of the legislature takes place in the various committees as they hear testimony and consider new bills.
So what kinds of folks make up the committee that will make major decisions about the evolution of health care reform in Vermont? I think that learning just a small amount about them helps gain a valuable perspective on how our democracy functions.
Our returning chair is Bill Lippert, a Democrat and 22-year member from Hinesburg. He is the former Executive Director of the Counseling Services of Addison County and a founder of a foundation for GBLT Vermonters.
The other two returning committee members are Tim Briglin, a Democrat from Thetford, and Doug Gage, a Republican from Rutland.
Tim was new last term and is the managing partner at Tuckerman Capital, a firm he co-founded in 2001 to invest in and grow small manufacturing businesses. Doug is starting his third term and is a tractor-trailer driver for Coca-Cola.
Sarah Copeland-Hanzas was majority leader for the Democrats last session, and now returns to the Health Care Committee, where she served since 2005. She is from Bradford, and is a science teacher as well as owner of local cafe.
Mike Hebert is a Republican from Vernon who has served on the Natural Resources Committee since 2010, and was moved to Health Care this year. He has background in the health care field in emergency medical systems.
Our five brand new members include a recent college graduate, Ben Jickling, who is an Independent from Brookfield and who works for the local golf course and for a youth mentoring program.
Annmarie Christensen is a Democrat from Weathersfield who has a background in journalism and communications in global public health, most recently at The Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice.
Lori Houghton is also a Democrat, from Essex Junction, whose background is as a sales operations specialist with LexisNexis, the online legal publishing firm.
Betsy Dunn of Essex Junction, a Democrat, is a labor and delivery nurse at the University of Vermont Medical Center, where she has also served the union as chief steward.
Brian Cicio of Burlington, a Progressive, is a clinical social worker with a private psychotherapy practice.
I round off our crew, and am the second longest serving House member on the committee, starting my 8th term. I was greatly honored this year to have been asked to serve as vice-chair.
We range in age from the 20s to 60s, but only two of us – me and Ben (who grew up working on his grandparents’ sheep farm in Chelsea) -- are native Vermonters.
During this past campaign season, now-Governor Phil Scott promoted the idea of a legislature that served only 10 weeks, restricting its focus to the annual state budget and saving on costs.
As much as I respect him and his views, I strongly disagree on this issue, because it would radically shift the balance of power between the executive and legislative branches of government.
It will take the rest of this month to learn the subjects at hand, and February into March will give a fairly narrow window to take on some of the significant subjects that demand attention. To name just a few: the crisis in our mental health system; oversight of the next stages of the “All Payer Model” for financing health care; identifying what we are going to do about Vermont Health Connect; addressing how Vermont will respond to the as-yet-unknown actions taken on the federal level, particularly their potential financial impact on our small state.
As we get to April, there will be little time for the committee to get further work done, as we will be on the House floor for debates and votes as bills emerge from committees; we will also need to focus on responding to bills that come from the Senate.
The decisions we make, flawed as they sometimes are, arise after hours of public testimony and public access to the process. They emerge through a process of discussion and often, compromise. They are aired in two bodies, both House and Senate.
The alternative would be that these decisions would be made by a single person, with input from appointed staff instead of elected representatives.
As clumsy and time-consuming and in-expert as it may be, I think the legislative process is vital and needs to be protected.

Thank you for the honor of representing you. Please contact me with your questions and your opinions. You can reach me by message at home at 485-6431, at the statehouse at 828-2228, or at this email at counterp@tds.net

Friday, December 2, 2016

Legislative Update: Gloom and Doom Day

Legislative Update: Gloom and Doom Day
December 1, 2016
Rep. Anne Donahue

In the past decade, the state’s Joint Fiscal Office has begun holding a one-day “preview” in the late fall so that legislators don’t get taken off guard about Vermont’s financial situation when they arrive at the statehouse in January. Some have begun to call it “gloom and doom” day, since it is never about good news.
This year, the state revenue forecast indicators that were presented looked pretty decent, but our fiscal experts said they “are worse than they look.”
Part of that is due to the huge uncertainty that comes with a new federal administration. Vermont’s highest risk factor in this area was a surprise to me: Exports are more important to Vermont’s economy than many other states. It’s 10.7 percent of our gross state product.
The national average is 8.4 percent, but for our immediate neighbors in New England, it’s 5.4 percent. So the share of our economy that is dependent on exports is nearly twice that of the rest of New England, and we were told that this puts us at higher risk if new federal economic policy includes increased tariffs that lead to wider trade wars. 
Rising exchange rates have already resulted in a 33 percent decline in our exports in the past four years. The strengthening dollar compared to a weak Canadian economy has hammered our exports to Canada, which have dropped from around 45 percent to 35 percent of our shrinking overall export market.
Our demographics also paint a scary longer-term issue. This is not a surprise, but it is getting worse. Our fertility rate has dropped to lowest in the nation, and our rate of change in the percentage of the working age population continues to drop.
Our aging “baby boom” bubble has a particular risk impact, because highest income years (i.e., income-tax-paying-years) are between ages 47 and 61; our big population drop-off begins to hit below age 55 and goes pretty straight downhill from there.
Meanwhile, our home price index has not yet returned to pre-recession levels (though it’s inching up and very close to that return.) That means it will continue to be education property tax rates – rather than increased grand lists resulting from increased home values – that will assume the brunt of increased education costs.
In some ways, that is a more legitimate indicator of the effect of larger school budgets. When I first came to the legislature, I used to point out that our comfortable position of being able to routinely reduce the tax rate created a fiction. Property taxes were skyrocketing because home values were increasing rapidly – rapidly enough that the rate could be reduced because the increases were covered by the inflation in values.
Ever since that ended with the recession, we have had to increase the statewide property tax rate, which is a more transparent reflection of the impact of increases in school budgets.
The fiscal presentation also reminded us of how heavily we rely on federal funds for our state budget (it makes up 35 percent of the total). Vermont is number four among the 50 states in the amount of federal funds received per capita, at close to $3,000 per capita compared to a national average of less than $2,000.
 That significantly increases our budget risk if federal policies change on funding of health care and social programs.
In terms of the immediate budget future, our annual structural gap between maintaining current state services and our projected revenues is $40 to $50 million this coming year. That is the pressure point that has resulted in new taxes being imposed every year in recent history. Closing the gap requires cutting spending, raising taxes, or supporting economic growth to increase the base for tax revenues (or some combination of those).
Increasing the base has been Governor-Elect Phil Scott’s mantra, but that isn’t something that can produce results instantly, so it will be a real challenge to avoid both major program cuts or new taxes or fees. We’ll receive his budget proposal in January.
There are other big budget pressures. We face a $68 million gap between current revenues (state and federal) and the costs required to clean up our state waters.  The needed investment is $120 million annually to meet federal requirements for a 34 percent phosphorus reduction over 20 years.
Not enough gloom and doom for you yet?
In January we are also being hit with a $5 million loss in federal funds for the current year budget plus another $6.2 million in the upcoming budget because of disallowed programs under our Medicaid waiver,  That waiver is our special deal (called the Global Commitment) that allows us greater flexibility in the uses of federal Medicaid money.
The feds have changed some rules, but we’ve also stretched the rules and gotten caught. The changes will amount to $64 million in lost funding for existing programs over the next 10 years.
The biggest chunk of that is for money we’re spending on psychiatric hospitals – the Brattleboro Retreat and our own new Vermont Psychiatric Care Hospital in Berlin – that are not integrated into a medical center, which is the usual requirement for federal funding.
The “good news” that was presented regarding the renewal of our Global Commitment was an increase in the federal funding we can access for investment in new health care programs over the next two years.
The increase from the current $127 million to $148 million is aimed specifically at Medicaid’s share of the start-up costs for health care reform under the All Payer waiver.
More federal money may sound good… but the catch is always that it is matching fund money, in other words, we only get more from the feds if we also spend more in new state money to meet our 46 percent share.

I look forward to providing my regular updates again after we convene in January. Please feel free to contact me at any time with questions or concerns. You can reach me at 485-6431 or by email at counterp@tds.net.



Thursday, October 27, 2016

Legislative Update on the All Payer Model

Legislative Update on Health Care Payment Reform: the All Payer Model
Rep. Anne Donahue
October 27, 2016

There is so much discussion and focus on the agreement that Vermont has just signed with the federal government for an “All Payer Model” for health care reform that – having sat through a lot of testimony before the House Health Care Committee – I thought I should share some comment and clarification.
For those who followed my legislative updates last spring, this is not something being sprung on the public out of nowhere, and it has not happened without involvement of the legislature.
That doesn’t mean it is good, or will work as intended; it just means that there was some process behind it.
So here are the clarifying points:
In terms of Medicare, Act 113, as passed by the legislature last spring, says that a condition of the authority of the Green Mountain Care Board and governor to sign was that the agreement cannot reduce Medicare covered services, increase Medicare patient cost sharing, or alter Medicare appeals processes.
In terms of the money, the language is that there can be no “conversion, appropriation, or aggregation” of Medicare money by the State of Vermont – Medicare money still must go directly to providers or provider organizations (Accountable Care Organizations), as it does now.
These organizations were created by the federal government, already exist and will continue to exist regardless of the “All Payer Model.” What the state is doing is including the ability for Medicaid and private insurance to come under an ACO.
We will end up with only one ACO because of the size of our state. An ACO takes on the risk of losing money, and a smaller pool of providers cannot take on that risk. The federal government recognizes that, which is why the agreement requires working to recruit the majority of doctors in the state to participate (and ergo, their patients.)
Having only one ACO does not mean (as some are saying) that the ACO is going to be controlled by UVM or the hospitals. The governance of the new ACO was negotiated over many months, includes community partners, and gives non-hospital members veto powers.
The legislature vetted the All Payer Model proposal in a number of committee hearings. Act 113 allowed for the process to move forward (and for it to be signed, once negotiated) only if it met a number of conditions, and with a long list of requirements for how it would be implemented.
If the “only if” terms are not met by the agreement, it is not legally binding, because the GMCB and governor do not have the authority to sign it.
All of the stakeholders who testified supported the wording of the detailed requirements that are a condition of implementation. The legislature passed Act 113 on an overwhelming, tri-partisan vote (quarto-partisan, if you include independents.)  
The consumer protection part of the bill was originally introduced by the Democratic Chair and Progressive Vice-Chair of our Health Care Committee. A separate bill that created conditions for any All Payer Model was introduced by the Independent on the committee jointly with the Republican raking member (me). The two were merged into the final bill.
The “devil of the details” will need to be developed through compliance with Act 113 and its oversight mechanisms. Unfortunately, there was very little news media coverage of Act 113 last spring, thus little public awareness of these discussions and requirements.
So is this new model – the idea of making the federal Medicare ACO plan much bigger, and including a majority of the state -- a good thing or a bad thing?
We don’t know. It has risks.
That worries a lot of people, legitimately, and is why the legislature placed so many restrictions on it, including requirements for ACO investments into primary care and community health care partners, and much more patient involvement in care decisions. (You can see the whole list by going to http://legislature.vermont.gov/, clicking on “bills and resolutions,” and looking up Act 113.)
I think that there are two big risks – first, of loss of quality, and second, of raising costs instead of saving costs.
 There is a fear that care will be rationed because of the incentive for doctors to provide fewer services, since they will get the same payments for patients whether there is a lot, or much less, care given.
The “counter” is that the system will be motivated to do more prevention (such as annual check-ups) and community-based care (such as home health) to prevent higher end costs when patients get sick from things that would have been preventable. This is because doctors would no longer be getting added reimbursement for those added costs.
The second major risk is that the whole new bureaucratic layer of the ACO will cost more than any of the savings. The savings theoretically come from better care outcomes, and the reduced bureaucratic burdens of answering differently to different payers.
My own opinion has been, and remains, that this whole thing is being over-sold on BOTH the potential benefits and the potential risks. I don’t think it is going to produce major change.
It assumes that the big cost drivers are unnecessary tests and unnecessary care being done just to make more money under “fee for service”, and I don’t think Vermont doctors do much of that.  It also assumes that we are losing a lot of money from bad care coordination, and I think that though far from perfect, we’ve already made a lot of progress on that.
There are many, much bigger cost drivers that will not be touched by these changes.
But I also think the risks are being over-stated. I don’t think our doctors will tolerate restriction on giving what they think is best patient care. I also don’t think we/ the state will tolerate this experiment if the administrative costs start skyrocketing.
There are not a lot of solid, viable alternatives being offered. The cost of doing nothing is placing a huge burden on all of us, including the tax burden of Medicaid, the economic burden on businesses paying for health care, and the burden of unaffordable premiums for individuals.
So with some reluctance, and some trepidation, I think it is appropriate to proceed, continuing one step at a time. Signing the agreement is just the first step.

But we can’t put our health reform eggs all in this basket. We need to be doing much more. My biggest single fear is that in portraying this as a big “solution,” we will avoid tackling other key issues, and that will contribute to the risk of failure.

Sunday, May 1, 2016

Legilative Update, May 1 2016


Legislative Update

Representative Anne Donahue

May 1, 2016

 

Perhaps the best way of demonstrating the chaos of the final week of the legislature is to share the calendar for Monday, May 2, even though those issues will be wrapped up by the time the Northfield News version of this column appears.

We are still, for now, mostly on the schedule that allows for three days of review of a bill. It is on notice for a day, is presented and debated at “second reading” the next day, and has a “third reading” the following day to give a chance for thorough consideration, plus any final amendments.

However we did expedite one day by having a “mock session” on Saturday. That means no one needed to be there, but the calendar moved ahead a day because bills on notice for Saturday will now be up for second reading on Monday. In addition, Monday is an added day to the schedule since we usually meet only Tuesday through Friday to allow time for those catching up on maintaining their full-time job responsibilities.

The big bills that need to pass will come at the end of the week, and will determine the actual closing day. They must pass because they include the general fund (operating budget) and the capital budget, plus the new tax and fee bills to pay for budget increases.

Anything else, including these Monday calendar items, will die if they are not finished when the money bills reach the finish line.

***

From Friday’s calendar:

Bills up for third reading:

Montpelier charter change: no controversy (the Berlin Pond section was struck), but it is a House bill, so it will still need to complete the Senate process. Because of the late date, we will likely “message our actions” to the Senate so that another day will not be lost.

Estate tax revisions: changes in the law that the Senate made that will generally reduce estate taxes, but includes the increase to the telecommunications fee that the House already passed but was not taken up by the Senate. The fee increase was controversial, but opposition was voted down (again) on Friday. It was added to the estate tax bill that the Senate sent over and wants, in order to force the Senate to address it, since the Senate will have to either accept the change or ask for a conference committee to resolve differences with the House. This is a common tactic.

Standardizing of some parts of environmental permits: no controversy, but it came from the Senate and the House made changes; the Senate will have to decide whether to accept the changes.

Permanency for children: no controversy, but from the Senate, and some changes made which will need Senate consideration. In addition, I have a proposed amendment. For long term guardianships, the bill permits a successor guardian to be appointed at the same time as the guardian, and an automatic change in custody then occurs if the guardian dies. I think that at that future time, there should be a new review by the court in case there are any changes in circumstances. (That kind of court review always happens in case of death of natural parents, even if they appointed a guardian in their wills.)

Approved absences from home detention: no controversy, Senate will need to approve House revisions.

Alcoholic beverage license changes: no controversy, Senate will need to approve House revisions.

Rental agreements if there is an unauthorized sub-lessee: no controversy, Senate will need to approve House revisions.

Bills up for second reading:

Bridport charter changes: no controversy, but will still need to complete the Senate process. Because of the late date, we will likely “suspend the rules” to move immediately to third reading and to “message our actions” to the Senate.

Drones, cell phones and license plate readers: this is a very big one, and rewritten from the Senate version. There will be lots of debate and potential amendments about the balance between citizen privacy protections and law enforcement needs. The Senate will undoubtedly want a conference committee, and if there is no agreement before the money bills finish their process, it will die.

Farm to school program: not likely to be controversial, Senate will need to approve House revisions.

Winooski charter changes: no controversy, but will need Senate action.

Barton charter changes: no controversy, but will need Senate action.

Government accountability committee revisions: no controversy and House is accepting the Senate bill without changes, so it will go straight to the governor.

Changes to the law defining independent contractors compared to employees. A major House bill that is coming to the House floor under a rarely used procedure. The Commerce Committee voted on it unanimously in March but it was sent back to the committee to hold pending input from a second committee. Others had major objections, and it stalled and was proclaimed “dead.” The unusual procedure was a motion and vote on the floor to “relieve the committee” of the bill and bring it to the House floor to proceed with second reading. It will be fiercely debated and may or may not pass. If it passes, it is highly unlikely that it will be taken up by the Senate since it is well beyond deadline with no time for Senate committee review. Nonetheless, many members felt it was important to hold a House vote.

Consideration of Senate changes to a House-passed bill:

Miscellaneous changes to criminal laws: no controversy or significant changes to the underlying House bill, and likely would have been accepted by the House. But! The Senate attached a bill that was stalled in the House (see process, estate bill, above) – the marijuana legalization bill, which sets up a major infrastructure for state oversight of sales. This will force the House to debate and vote on the Senate bill (or vote as a whole to send it to a House committee). Yes, expect a very extended debate, with an uncertain outcome. Most pundits believe it is highly unlikely to pass, in particular with no changes from this original Senate version. If a changed version does pass the House at some point, the Senate will have to decide whether to accept it as sent, or to ask for a conference committee where there are good chances it would die – if for no other reason than running out of time.

From Saturday’s Calendar:

Bills Up for Second Reading:

Pay Act for State Employees: likely to engender controversy, since fully funding the newly established contract would either require a further budget increase or – as the bill proposes -- partial cuts (through attrition) of the state workforce. The Senate had the contract information in time to include it in its version of the budget; the budget is currently back under House review.

Revisions to existing law for labelling of marijuana used for medical symptom relief: possibly some controversy, and the Senate will need to approve House revisions.

Combatting opiod abuse: a major bill that will likely raise questions and discussion, the Senate will need to review significant House revisions and it will likely request a conference committee.

Notifying patients about doctor office changes: no controversy, but Senate will need to accept House changes.

Consideration of Senate changes to a House-passed bill:

Hunting, fishing and trapping law revisions: no controversy, but House committee may ask for time to review Senate changes.

Transportation construction budget: House committee will ask for conference committee on multiple Senate changes.

Capital budget: House committee will ask for conference committee on multiple Senate changes.

Conference Committee Report:

Police body camera rules: Senate and House disagreed on differences in bills passed, so a conference committee was appointed and has come to agreement. Both bodies must approve the agreement, but these are usually always approved.

The Rest of the Week

There will be more and more pressure to suspend the usual rules of process to speed bills through. That will happen for anything non-controversial.

It used to also happen for major bills that the majority party (the Democrats) wanted passed, even extremely lengthy bills, including the budget itself. There was often no time to even actually read a bill before it was voted on.

Eight years ago I provoke a rebellion over this process, which does a serious disservice to our constituents. Thus was born the unofficial “24 hour rule.”

It requires a three-quarter vote to suspend the rules, so a minority party (the Republicans, though not the Progressives) can block a rules suspension. At the start of that next session, Republican leadership notified the Speaker that we would no longer go along with suspending rules without at least 24 hours to review any controversial bill, unless there we had internal consensus that we had had enough time to read and understand it. We extend that courtesy on behalf of the Progressives and any Independent if they feel they needed the full 24 hours.

It has spawned its own new opportunity for political gamesmanship. The Democrats will tell the press that Republicans are the cause of delaying adjournment. The Republicans, in turn, sometimes use the rule to its benefit by negotiating the timeline in exchange for a bill it wants to see pass.

But there is a bottom line: we should never be passing bills before legislators have enough time to read and understand them, and 24 hours is a reasonable standard to insist upon.

***

Thanks for the honor of representing you! You can contact me or Rep. Patti Lewis by email (counterp@tds.net for me; pattijlewis@myfairpoint.net for Patti) or by leaving a message at the statehouse at 828-2228. We welcome your feedback and input.

 

 

Sunday, April 17, 2016

Legislative Update April 16, 2016


Legislative Update

Representative Anne Donahue

April 16, 2016

 

Our target closing date for the session is May 6, which means we are finishing our House committee work on bills sent by the Senate in anticipation of several busy weeks in conference committees with the Senate working out differences. Politics will be at its highest levels in these final works, since it will be the last chance for various priorities to make it across the finish line.

Already, the marijuana legalization bill is taking strange courses on its likely path to a conference committee. It’s anyone’s guess what will emerge for final House and Senate votes.

A bill reforming the labor laws regarding independent contractors will likely fall to a political death. It was the product of extensive bipartisan work in the House Commerce Committee. This has long been a tricky area of law, trying to protect workers from being exploited and losing access to employer-paid worker’s comp and unemployment insurance, without being a barrier to individuals who are truly working for themselves. Emerging new technology fields require evolution of old standards, and the committee worked for many weeks to craft a bill that won unanimous support across its political spectrum. It is the most important economic development work of the House this year.

It was derailed from reaching the House floor for a vote in an almost unprecedented way. After the labor lobby objected to changes from current law, some powerful liberal legislators pushed to get the bill sent back to the Commerce Committee for “more work.” There it sits, well past the deadline for crossing over to the Senate and unlikely to be permitted out of committee despite the committee’s own vote to move it forward.

***

In my Health Care Committee, we are addressing Senate bills that deal with updating managed care and hospital regulation; creating better prescription cost transparency for health plans; blocking vision care plans from limiting the suppliers that optometrists can access; and requiring notice to patients when their provider practice is bought by a hospital. Each has its own labyrinth of detail to unravel, and presents opportunities to add last-minute new proposals. Late session bills are sometimes called “Christmas trees” because so many add-on “decorations” are placed on the underlying bill. The process keeps lobbyists hopping as they try to track issues for their clients.

A piece I tried to add to the hospital regulation bill this past week gives a good snapshot into the role of lobbyists: a role that, at least in Vermont, usually is not the nefarious one that is often assumed.

I’ve long been more than a little annoyed about the way our non-profit hospitals conduct their business behind closed doors. They receive huge amounts of public money as well as the health care resource dollars that we pay in insurance, but develop their policies in private board meeting. More than a decade ago I led a battle to require that meetings be open unless confidential or proprietary information was being discussed. It a political hot potato – hospitals are powerful political players – and the effort failed.

We did get a requirement through back then that hospitals list on their websites the names of board members and the means for “obtaining a schedule of meetings of the hospital's governing body, including times scheduled for public participation.” Unfortunately with a few notable exceptions – the University of Vermont Medical Center as the shining example – most have no times scheduled for any such public participation.

The Senate bill we were working on includes updating some of the information reporting requirements, creating the opportunity for me to propose an new open board meeting clause. It rapidly gained positive traction among some members of my committee.

And panic from the hospital association’s lobbyist.

Unlike a regular bill that provides for lots of advance notice and discussion, this amendment to an existing bill could be on a fast track, and she had concerns on behalf of her client members. She articulated them rapidly: would this create a chilling effect on recruitment for these volunteer board positions? Block open discussion of tricky policy matters? How would “confidential” be defined? What about emergency meetings?

She proposed an alternative. She offered her commitment to work with her members and in particular to discuss with and learn from how UVMMC has been successfully achieving its open meeting process. She would then come back next year with a concrete proposal for how to create a hospital governing process that is more transparent and welcoming of public participation. In exchange, we would agree to hold off on rushing anything into a bill this year, in favor of it receiving full vetting.

My proposed amendment might, or might not, have made it through the committee process, House floor debate, and Senate approval. The hospitals would have been fighting vigorously. Next year, there will be turnover in the legislature, and the issue may well lay dormant.

But I have worked with this lobbyist for many years now, and I know she is a person of her word. We have collaborated on issues of shared concerns, debated vigorously on others, and agreed to disagree on some, and but always with mutual respect. With my agreement to withdraw my proposal, she has protected her clients from a potentially not-well-thought out and disruptive new mandate. However I have gained a commitment for development of an approach that will have a far greater prospect of consensus, and thus, of actually becoming law next year.

The product will be better. The public will be better served. The process will have worked, through the help of a lobbyist during her job. 

***

My committee is also continuing its work on trying to craft a bill that will force disclosures from pharmaceutical manufacturers about how they create – and justify – cost structures and cost increases. The concept is simple. Drug companies defend high prices based on the costs of developing and testing new drugs. We want to say, “Prove it. Put up or shut up. Show us the money trail.”

Some drugs that have been on the market for years suddenly spike in price. Why? We can’t try to protect consumers and build cost containment without knowing what actually drives the costs. There are efforts in multiple states to try to push for this information, and it is likely that these very profitable businesses will fight back with lawsuits.

We have long passed the deadline to get this bill to the Senate. It thus has little chance of actually passing this year. It would remain as only an expression of intent of the Vermont House. But I think it’s a conversation worth trying to force, and a public challenge to pharmaceutical companies worth making. It’s a battle that needs to be fought one step at a time.

***

Thanks for the honor of representing you! You can contact me or Rep. Patti Lewis by email (counterp@tds.net for me; pattijlewis@myfairpoint.net for Patti) or by leaving a message at the statehouse at 828-2228. We welcome your feedback and input.

 

 

 

Anne B. Donahue